Русская версия English version

Improvement of the algorithm for calculating the equivalent circuit parameters of an induction motor and comparison with existing industrial software tools

A.E. Petrov, V.D. Lebedev

Vestnik IGEU, 2025 issue 5, pp. 59—67

Download PDF

Abstract in English: 

Background. The calculation of equivalent circuit parameters of induction motors according to nameplate data is widely used in engineering practice and implemented in several software packages (such as MATLAB, ETAP, Power Factory, and others). However, such tools do not always provide reliable reproduction of starting characteristics or accurate control of deviations from nameplate values. In some cases, physically inconsistent results are observed, such as the appearance of two extrema on the electromagnetic torque curve. In domestic practice, algorithms have been developed that are suitable for adaptation and integration into modern calculation tools, as well as a software prototype for simulating electromechanical transients.

Materials and methods. The study is based on equivalent circuit models of induction motors. Various mathematical approximation methods have been applied to describe the dependence of circuit parameters on slip. The materials include nameplate and experimental data of 45 induction motors of different power ratings, rotational speeds, and applications.

Results. Several alternative approaches to approximating the dependence of the equivalent circuit parameters of induction motors on slip have been examined. Particular attention has been devoted to the selection of mathematical formulations capable of ensuring improved accuracy in reproducing both starting and rated characteristics. To assess the effectiveness of the proposed methodology, a series of computations has been carried out on a dataset of 45 motors with varying rated power, rotational speeds, and industrial applications. The results of the study have revealed certain instabilities and specific features of existing algorithms implemented in widely used software packages, including cases that resulted in an unreliable representation of the electromechanical characteristic.

Conclusions. The conducted study has shown that the use of alternative approaches to approximating the equivalent circuit parameters makes it possible to significantly reduce the error when calculating the starting and operating characteristics of induction motors compared with conventional methods. The proposed approach has demonstrated more stable and accurate reproduction of nameplate parameters across a wide range of motor types, thereby covering a broad spectrum of typical operating conditions and improving the reliability of the obtained results. The modification of the rotor parameter approximation algorithm with respect to slip substantially enhances the accuracy of equivalent circuit calculations, particularly in the field of starting characteristics. The proposed expressions provide a more consistent functional form without complicating computations. The developed approach is intended for and recommended to be incorporated into domestic engineering software tools aimed at simulating electromechanical transients in power systems.

References in English: 

1. Syromyatnikov, I.A. Rezhimy raboty asinkhronnykh i sinkhronnykh elektrodvigateley [Operating Modes of Induction and Synchronous Motors]. Moscow: Energoatomizdat, 1984. 240 p.

2. Zhukov, V.V. Korotkie zamykaniya v uzlakh kompleksnoy nagruzki elektricheskikh sistem [Short circuits in complex load nodes of electrical systems]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo MPEI, 1994. 224 p.

3. Gamazin, S.I., Stavtsev, V.A., Tsyruk, S.A. Perekhodnye protsessy v sistemakh promyshlennogo elektrosnabzheniya, obuslovlennye elektrodvigatel'noy nagruzkoy [Transient Processes in Industrial Power Supply Systems Caused by Motor Loads]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo MEI, 1997. 424 p.

4. Dmitrenko, A.M., Kazakova, E.Yu., Atamanov, M.N. Analiz perekhodnykh protsessov differentsial'nykh zashchit transformatorov s moshchnoy dvigatel'noy nagruzkoy [Analysis of Transient Processes in Transformer Differential Protection with Heavy Motor Loads]. Releynaya zashchita i avtomatizatsiya, 2012, no. 1(6), pp. 38–42.

5. Shuin, V.A., Frolova, O.V. Modelirovanie rezhimov samozapuska elektrodvigateley sobstvennykh nuzhd elektrostantsiy: UMP / IGEU [Modeling of self-starting modes of electric motors for auxiliary needs of power plants: UMP / ISPU]. Ivanovo, 2004. 64 p.

6. Pedra, Joaquin. On the Determination of Induction Motor Parameters From Manufacturer Data for Electromagnetic Transient Programs. IEEE® Transactions on Power Systems, November 2008, vol. 23, no. 4, pp. 1709–1718.

7. Zherve, G.K. Promyshlennye ispytaniya elektricheskikh mashin [Industrial Testing of Electrical Machines]. Leningrad: Energiya, 1968. 575 p.

8. Vol'dek, A.I., Popov, V.V. Elektricheskie mashiny. Mashiny peremennogo toka [Electric Machines. AC Machines]. Saint-Petersburg: Piter, 2007.

9. Hossein-Ali, Kakai. Dynamic Analysis of Three Phase Induction Motor in DigSilent Powerfactory. ENG460 Engineering Thesis, School of Engineering and Information Technology, Murdoch University. Perth, Australia, 2014. 76 p.

10. Georgiadi, V.Kh. (ed.) Metodika rascheta rezhimov pereryva pitaniya i samozapuska elektrodvigateley 3–10 kV sobstvennykh nuzhd elektrostantsiy uproshchennymi metodami [Methodology for Calculating Power Interruption and Self-Start Modes of 3–10 kV Auxiliary Power Motors at Power Plants Using Simplified Methods]. Moscow: ORGRES, 1992. 144 p.

11. Lifshits, A.S., Yablokov, A.A., Murzin, A.Yu., Petrov, A.E., Panashchatenko, A.V. Oblachnyy servis «Laboratoriya RZA» [Cloud service “Laboratory RZA”]. Svidetel'stvo o gosudarstvennoy registratsii programmy dlya EVM RF [Certificate of State Registration of Computer Program in Russia]. No. 2025619089, 2025.

12. Petrov, A.E. Programma rascheta parametrov skhemy zameshcheniya asinkhronnogo elektrodvigatelya s nominal'nym napryazheniem do i vyshe 1 kV [Program for calculating the parameters of the equivalent circuit of an asynchronous electric motor with a rated voltage of up to and above 1 kV]. Svidetel'stvo o gosudarstvennoy registratsii programmy dlya EVM RF [Certificate of State Registration of Computer Program in Russia]. No. 2024664870, 2024.

Key words in Russian: 
асинхронный электродвигатель, схема замещения электродвигателя, пусковые характеристики, идентификация параметров, электромеханическая модель, инженерное программное обеспечение
Key words in English: 
induction motor, equivalent circuit of an electric motor, starting characteristics, parameter identification, electromechanical model, engineering software
The DOI index: 
10.17588/2072-2672.2025.5.059-067
Downloads count: 
12