Русская версия English version

Multi-frequency directional protection against earth faults in uncompensated 6–10 kV networks

K.S. Aleshin, N.V. Kuzmina, A.A. Semushkin, T.Y. Shadrikova, V.A. Shuin

Vestnik IGEU, 2025 issue 5, pp. 39—49

Download PDF

Abstract in English: 

Background. For selective protection against single-phase earth faults in uncompensated 6–10 kV networks with isolated neutral or high-resistance resistive neutral grounding, maximum current and current directional zero-sequence protections are most widely used. Higher technical perfection (selectivity and stability of operation) is provided by current directional protection against single-phase earth faults. Almost all known modern digital designs of directional current zero-sequence protections of various manufacturers are based on monitoring the phase ratios of the components of the fundamental frequency of voltage and current of zero-sequence. It ensures an increase of their selectivity, but not always sufficient sensitivity in the most dangerous for the network and damaged connection arc intermittent earth faults. Therefore, the task to develop current directional zero-sequence protection with high technical perfection, both for stable and arc earth faults, is relevant. In our opinion, such designs of directional current zero-sequence protection can be obtained on the basis of a multi-frequency approach. It assumes the use of both the fundamental frequency components and the higher harmonic components of the steady-state and transient modes of single-phase earth faults in 6–10 kV networks.

Materials and methods. Considering the complexity of transient processes during arc earth faults in medium-voltage electric networks and the algorithms of the operation of relay protection devices based on the use of electrical quantities of transient processes in electric power facilities, the main research method is mathematical modeling using simulation models of 6–10 kV cable and overhead networks with an isolated neutral or with high-resistance resistive grounding of the neutral, and a model of the algorithm for the operation of multi-frequency directional protection against earth faults. They are implemented using the Simulink application program and the SimPowerSystems block library of the Matlab software package.

Results. The principles of implementation of multi-frequency directional protection against single-phase earth faults in cable and overhead networks with voltage of 6–10 kV are substantiated and an algorithm of its operation is developed. The results of the functional tests on simulation models of cable and overhead 6–10 kV networks, operating both with an isolated neutral and with neutral grounding through a high-ohm resistor, confirmed the efficiency of the developed principles of implementation and the algorithm of operation of multi-frequency directional protection for all considered types of single-phase earth faults.

Conclusions. The proposed technical solution implements a multi-frequency principle of directional protection against single-phase earth faults in 6–10 kV cable and overhead distribution networks with isolated neutral and high-resistance neutral grounding. It provides higher selectivity and sensitivity compared to traditional directional current protection based on the use of only fundamental frequency components, both for stable and for the most dangerous arc intermittent earth faults for the network.

References in English: 

1. Likhachev, F.A. Zamykaniya na zemlyu v setyakh s izolirovannoy neytral'yu i s kompensatsiey emkostnykh tokov [Groundfaults in networks with isolated neutral and with capacitive currents compensation]. Moscow: Energiya, 1971. 152 p.

2. Fedoseev, A.M. Releynaya zashchita elektroenergeticheskikh sistem. Releynaya zashchita setey [Relay protection of electrical systems. Relay protection of networks]. Moscow: Energoatomizdat, 1984. 560 p.

3. Shabad, M.A. Raschety releynoy zashchity i avtomatiki raspredelitel'nykh setey [Calculations of relay protection and automation of distribution networks]. Saint-Petersburg: PEIPK, 2003. 350 p.

4. Shuin, V.A., Gusenkov, A.V. Zashchity ot zamykaniy na zemlyu v elektricheskikh setyakh 6–10 kV [Protection against groundfaults in 6–10 kV electrical networks]. Moscow: NTF «Energoprogress», 2001. 104 p.

5. Dudarev, L.E., Zaporozhchenko, S.I., Luk'yantsev, N.M. Dugovye zamykaniya na zemlyu v kabel'nykh setyakh [Arc groundfault in cable networks]. Elektricheskie stantsii, 1971, no. 8, pp. 64–66.

6. Khalilov, F.Kh., Evdokunin, G.A., Polyakov, V.S. Zashchita setey 6–35 kV ot perenapryazheniy [Protection of 6–35 kV networks from overvoltage]. Saint-Petersburg: Energoatomizdat, 2002. 272 p.

7. Shadrikova, T.Yu. Razrabotka kompleksnoy mnogofunktsional'noy zashchity ot odnofaznykh zamykaniy na zemlyu kabel'nykh setey 6–10 kV. Diss. … kand. tekhn. nauk [Development of principles for the implementation of complex multifunctional protection against single phase groundfaults of 6–10 kV cable networks. Cand. tech. sci. diss.]. Ivanovo, 2016. 204 p.

8. Al'-Khomidi, M.S., Dobryagina, O.A., Shagurina, E.S., Shadrikova, T.Yu., Shuin, V.A. Otsenka chuvstvitel'nosti tokovykh zashchit ot zamykaniy na zemlyu v kabel'nykh setyakh 6–10 kV [Evaluation of sensitivity of current protection against earth faults in 6–10 kV cable networks]. Vestnik IGEU, 2016, issue 3, pp. 50–55.

9. Vaynshteyn, V.L. Issledovanie vysshikh garmonik toka zamykaniya na zemlyu [Investigation of the higher harmonics of the groundfault current]. Promyshlennaya energetika, 1986, no. 1, pp. 39–40.

10. Ol'shovets, P. Admitansnye zashchity – effektivnoe sredstvo okhrany setey SN ot zamykaniy na zemlyu [Admittance protection – an effective means of protecting low voltage networks from ground faults]. Releynaya zashchita i avtomatizatsiya, 2017, no. 3(28), pp. 56–59.

11. Wahlroos, A., Altonen, J. Multifrequency admittance protection. Wiadomości Elektrotechniczne, 2016, vol. 12.

12. Popov, I.N., Lachugin, V.F., Sokolova, G.V. Releynaya zashchita, osnovannaya na kontrole perekhodnykh protsessov [Relay protection based on transient process monitoring]. Moscow: Energoatomizdat, 1986.

13. Shuin, V.A. Nachal'nye fazovye sootnosheniya elektricheskikh velichin perekhodnogo protsessa pri zamykaniyakh na zemlyu v kabel'nykh setyakh 6–10 kV [Initial phase relationships of electrical quantities of the transient process during ground faults in 6–10 kV cable networks]. Elektrichestvo, 1991, no. 10, pp. 58–61.

14. Gonorovskiy, I.S. Radiotekhnicheskie tsepi i signaly [Radio engineering circuits and signals]. Moscow: Sovetskoe radio, 1977.

15. Shirman, Ya.D., Manzhos, V.N. Teoriya i tekhnika obrabotki radiolokatsionnoy informatsii na fone pomekh [Theory and technology of processing radar information against the background of interference]. Moscow: Radio i svyaz', 1981.

16. Filatova, G.A. Razrabotka i issledovanie sposobov i algoritmov opredeleniya mesta odnofaznogo zamykaniya na zemlyu v kabel'nykh setyakh 6–10 kV po parametram perekhodnogo protsessa. Diss. … kand. tekhn. nauk [Development and study of methods and algorithms for determining the location of a single-phase ground fault in 6–10 kV cable networks based on the parameters of the transient process. Cand. tech. sci. diss.]. Ivanovo, 2017.

Key words in Russian: 
некомпенсированные сети 6–10 кВ, однофазные замыкания на землю, мультичастотная направленная защита от замыканий на землю
Key words in English: 
6–10 kV uncompensated networks, single-phase earth faults, multi-frequency directional earth fault protection
The DOI index: 
10.17588/2072-2672.2025.5.039-049
Downloads count: 
11