Русская версия English version

Methodology to analyze the economic efficiency of using a thermohydraulic distributor in heat substations

V.V. Smirnov, Y.V. Yavorovskiy, M.V. Kozlova, N.N. Smirnov, S.I. Shuvalov

Vestnik IGEU, 2026 issue 5, pp. 20—30

Download PDF

Abstract in English: 

Background. An analysis of the use of thermohydraulic distributors in heat substations has revealed a lack of research of the efficiency of the proposed configuration compared to conventional and modern consumer connection schemes in district heating systems. It is necessary to provide a theoretical basis and a quantitative assessment of the factors determining the techno-economic efficiency of using thermohydraulic distributors in heat substation layouts, as well as to establish the operational limits of their effective use. This task is timely and holds significant practical importance.

Materials and methods. Economic efficiency has been determined using comparative calculation methods and specially developed computer programs. The results have been processed using mathematical statistical methods and specifically regression analysis.

Results. A methodology has been developed to determine the economic efficiency of using a thermohydraulic distributor in a heat distribution unit under various temperature schedules. Nomograms are proposed to estimate the economic impact of implementing such a distributor. It has been established that maximum efficiency is achieved in low-temperature, low-pressure district heating systems where consumer units lack automatic heat flow controllers.

Conclusions. It has been determined that there is no economic benefit to using a scheme with a thermohydraulic distributor in heat supply systems employing quantitative or combined qualitative-quantitative regulation.

References in English: 

1. Smirnov, V.V., Yavorovsky, Yu.V., Sennikov, V.V., Romanov, D.O. Sravnitel′nyy analiz effektivnosti primeneniya termogidravlicheskogo raspredelitelya s klassicheskimi skhemami prisoedineniya abonentov [Comparative analysis of the efficiency of using a thermohydraulic distributor versus classical consumer connection schemes]. Vestnik IGEU, 2019, issue 3, pp. 5–13.

2.  Romanov, D.O., Yavorovskiy, Yu.V., Smirnov, V.V. Eksperimental′nye issledovaniya rezhimov raboty termogidravlicheskogo raspredelitelya [Experimental studies of the operating modes of a thermohydraulic distributor]. Nadezhnost′ i bezopasnost′ energetiki, 2019, no. 2, pp. 106–112.

3.  Romanov, D.O., Yavorovskiy, Yu.V., Sennikov, V.V., Smirnov, V.V. Eksperimental′nye issledovaniya i chislennoe modelirovanie rezhimov raboty termogidravlicheskogo raspredelitelya [Experimental studies and numerical modeling of the operating modes of a thermohydraulic distributor]. Energosberezhenie: teoriya i praktika, 2018, pp. 233–237.

4.  Smirnov, V.V., Yavorovskiy, Yu.V., Sennikov, V.V. Eksperimental′noe podtverzhdenie lokalizatsii peremennykh gidravlicheskikh rezhimov v teplovykh punktakh s termogidravlicheskim raspredelitelem [Experimental confirmation of the localization of variable hydraulic regimes in heat substations equipped with a thermohydraulic distributor]. Vestnik IGEU, 2018, issue 6, pp. 5–14.

5.  Semenov, V.G., Baron, V.G., Razgovorov, A.S. Individual′nye teplovye punkty novogo pokoleniya [New-generation individual heat substations]. ENERGOSOVET, 2017, no. 48, pp. 15–18.

6.  Il′in, R.A., Stolyarov, D.V. Kompleksnaya modernizatsiya teplovykh punktov v sistemakh tsentralizovannogo teplosnabzheniya [Comprehensive modernization of heat substations in district heating systems]. Simvol nauki, 2015, no. 12-1, pp. 42–45.

7.  Savina, N.V., Artyushevskaya, E.Yu. Upravlenie teplosnabzheniem: sovremennye individual′nye teplovye punkty [Heat supply management: modern individual heat substations].  Vestnik AmGU, 2017, no. 79, pp. 55–59.

8.  Ignatek, V.V., Borovkov, V.M. Analiz metodov regulirovaniya otpuskov teplovoy energii [Analysis of methods for regulating thermal energy supply]. Materialovedenie. Energetika, 2010, no. 2-2(100), pp. 65–71.

9.   Chernenkov, V.P., Likhachev, I.D., Baryshev, M.S., Rakhmatulina, M.B. Raschet grafikov regulirovaniya teplovoy nagruzki v nezavisimykh avtomatizirovannykh sistemakh teplosnabzheniya [Calculation of thermal load regulation schedules in independent automated heat supply systems]. Vestnik inzhenernoy shkoly DVFU, 2017, no. 3(32), pp. 27–31.

10. Smirnov, V.V., Yavorovskiy, Yu.V., Zalaev, D.R, Romanov, D.O. Raschet tekhniko-ekonomicheskikh pokazateley teplosnabzheniya pri ispol′zovanii TGR v TP [Calculation of technical and economic indicators of heat supply using TGR in heat substations]. Svidetel'stvo o gosudarstvennoy registratsii programmy dlya EVM v Rossii [Certificate of state registration of computer program in Russian Federation]. No. 2019619037, 2019.

Key words in Russian: 
термогидравлический распределитель, автоматизированный индивидуальный тепловой пункт, система централизованного теплоснабжения, технико-экономическая эффективность
Key words in English: 
thermohydraulic distributor, automated individual heat substation, district heating system, techno-economic efficiency
The DOI index: 
10.17588/2072-2672.2026.5.020-030
Downloads count: 
4